As a former Engineer, it always requires further explanation whenever someone asks me, “I hear the Real Estate market is really good. Is that true?”
I usually respond with, “That depends. Are you looking to buy, sell, or trade equity of an existing home?”
The reaction I get is usually best explained by the facial expression that says, “Huh?” or “Yeah…whatever.”
To put things simply, the Real Estate market goes through momentum swings, just like any market. However, to say the market is “bad” or “good” is definitely oversimplifying things.
Most agree that today’s market is an appreciating market. Prices have not yet peaked. When the market is appreciating, it often leads to some of the worst decision making by buyers and sellers due to confusion.
Common sense would tell us that increasing values is good for everyone. Unfortunately, this is not the case in Real Estate. For some folks, it’s the opposite of what would seem is common sense. There’s an old saying, “Money is made when you buy.”
Let’s create a few groups of people affected by the market:
A. First-time homebuyers. This group includes anyone that is buying without having to sell a property in the same market location and segment.
B. Move-up buyer. This is a homeowner who needs to sell their existing home in order to move in a more expensive home. This includes a homeowner who decides to take a “cash out” loan on their existing home to use as a downpayment on another home. Both transactions are happening within the same market location and segment.
C. Downsizing seller. This is a homeowner who needs to sell their existing home in order to move in a less expensive home. This includes a homeowner who decides to take a “cash out” loan on their existing home to use as a downpayment on another home. Both transactions are happening within the same market location and segment.
D. Cash out seller. This is a homeowner who is simply selling and will not buy under the current market conditions.
Keep in mind that this table shows who benefits from a financial standpoint and assumes sellers have enough equity for a downpayment toward their upleg home.
“I’m going to wait until my home value goes higher.”
Most sellers think this is the smart move. Unfortunately, you can see from the chart above that only the “cash out” seller is the only one who would benefit from waiting. For the other sellers, their replacement home becomes more expensive as well and the choices of homes become fewer. Even for the “cash out” seller, the problem with this particular strategy is that you must predict if the market has peaked.
One example that comes to mind during a hot market: The market becomes more attractive to “move up” buyers because they are happy their home has increased in value. I have a client right now who could’ve sold her home last year for $485,000. The larger more expensive home would’ve costed about $650,000 within the same market.
Today, her home is worth $515,000, a gain of $30,000. Sounds like a good thing she waited, right? Wrong. The replacement home now sells for around $725,000, an increase in $75,000! In addition to the gap widening between her home and the replacement home, closing costs, commissions, and taxes will be higher due to the higher sales prices.
Ultimately, dollars and cents aren’t what decisions are based on. The best time to buy or sell is when you are ready. Life does not wait for optimal Real Estate markets. Just don’t kid yourself in thinking that waiting for higher prices will benefit all situations.